Title

Revisiting the Enclave Hypothesis: Miami Twenty-Five Years Later

Author(s)

Alejandro Portes Alejandro Portes (Princeton University)

Steven Shafer Steven Shafer (Princeton University)

Abstract

We review the empirical literature on ethnic economic enclaves after the concept was formulated twenty-five years ago. The balance of this literature is mixed, but many studies reporting negative conclusions were marred by faulty measurement of the concept. We discuss the original theoretical definition of enclaves, the hypotheses derived from it, and the difficulties in operationalizing them. For evidence, we turn to census data on the location and the immigrant group that gave rise to the concept in the first place - Cubans in Miami. We examine the economic performance of this group, relative to others in this metropolitan area, and in the context of historical changes in its own mode of incorporation. Taking these changes into account, we find that the ethnic enclave had a significant economic payoff for its founders - the earlier waves of Cuban exiles - and for their children, but not for refugees who arrived in the 1980 Mariel exodus and after. Reasons for this disjuncture are examined. Implications of these results for enclave theory and for immigrant entrepreneurship in general are discussed.

Creation Date

2006-05

Section URL ID

CMD

Paper Number

wp0610.pdf

URL

http://cmd.princeton.edu/sites/cmd/files/working-papers/papers/wp0610.pdf

File Function

Jel

F22, R23

Keyword(s)

Suppress

false

Series

7